Chapter 4 - The Defense Attorney’s Gamble

By New Year's Eve, the story had broken through local news channels and exploded across social media. Headlines blared “CHRISTMAS EVE HORROR: FATHER ACCUSED OF FREEZING CHRONICALLY ILL DAUGHTER FOR INSURANCE PAYOUT.” Online sleuths dissected every detail of the smart-home logs, turning our family tragedy into a viral true-crime spectacle.
I was sitting in a corner booth of a diner three blocks from the hospital, nursing a cup of lukewarm coffee, when my phone rang. An unknown number flashing with a downtown area code.
"Miss Vance?" a smooth, professional voice asked. "My name is Julian Vance—no relation to the defendant, I assure you—and I represent Arthur Vance."
My grip tightened on the ceramic mug. "If you're calling to offer a plea deal, save your breath. There's a paper trail a mile long, insurance policies in the attic, and toxicology reports from the ICU."
"I'm not calling about a plea," Julian said smoothly, his tone unruffled. "I'm calling because my client has instructed me to file an emergency motion for a psychological evaluation, and as part of that defense strategy, we are preparing to submit an alternate timeline of events."
"Alternate timeline?" I scoffed. "What timeline explains locking a dying girl in an unheated garage with a brass padlock?"
"The timeline where Mr. Vance was acting under extreme emotional distress caused by your sister's own self-destructive behavior," the attorney countered, his voice sharpening. "We have documentation from three different behavioral health specialists indicating that the patient suffered from severe Munchausen syndrome by proxy—or rather, self-inflicted medical tampering designed to manipulate household finances and draw attention away from her own mounting debts."
The blood rushed in my ears. "That's a lie. She was fighting to stay alive!"
"Is she?" Julian asked softly. "Because our investigators have pulled her private browser history from her personal laptop. Searches for 'how to fake oxygen deprivation,' 'lethal doses of barbiturates,' and 'how to trigger smart-home sensor failures.' All originating from her IP address, using her login credentials, while Mr. Vance was downstairs watching television."
The line went silent except for the faint hum of cellular static.
"Think about it, Miss Vance," the lawyer continued, driving the knife in deeper. "Who stands to gain the most if the estate goes to probate uncontested? Who had admin rights to the home network before your father ever touched that tablet?"
He hung up before I could answer.
May you like
I sat there in the empty booth, staring at my reflection in the dark diner window, a cold spike of doubt twisting in my chest. Could she? No. I pushed the thought away instantly. But as I stared at the screen of my phone, a terrible realization dawned on me: my father’s defense team wasn't trying to prove he was innocent.
They were trying to build a narrative where both of them were monsters, dragging my sister down into the dirt right beside him.